Saturday, July 22, 2006

I hate Adam Gopnik

Ok, this post is, i am sure, a complete argument against drinking & blogging. Against drinking, period. The problem with drinking is that it makes you maudlin.

Not that poor Adam Gopnik has done anything to deserve my hate. He was simply at the right place, at the right time, and wrote a lovely book about it, years ago. It just pisses me off that his story ended happily, and mine didn't....but it is kind of odd that i am harping on that particular point after all these years.

See, Adam Gopnik and his wife moved to Paris for a few years, spent some time there as your (not-so) standard American ex-pats, had a baby, moved back. And he wrote about it -- he is a writer, after all. It's the 'had a baby' part that always gets me in the gut.

I read the story of his daughter's birth in a hospital in Paris in the New Yorker when i was still a grad student at UVa with no Parisian aspirations at all. But shortly thereafter i applied for a grant to go research abroad, and a year+ therafter i found myself pregnant and in Paris; and i remembered this article. (which became a chapter in the book, i imagine, though i cannot myself open this book) What do i remember? The taxi-driver who had to be convinced to make the illegal u-turn when Mrs. G was in labor; the doctor in the stylin' black t-shirt; the startling change when the leisurely labor turned into an emergency c-section; the little girl born squealing; the fact that they brought Mrs. G a glass of red wine with her dinner after the birth (in the hospital). A shocking glass of red wine, for us Americans, i suppose. (For what it's worth, i didn't get any glasses of wine when it was my turn)

So anyway, as i went to my pre-natal appointments with Nicolas, i remembered this article. As i took a taxi home one day because i was throwing up all over the place, but gave up on convincing the driver to make an illegal u-turn ("no problem, it is just there, i will walk", clutching my baggie of vomit) , i remembered this article. I knew the book had come out, and what it was called, but i didn't go get it -- thinking it was silly to buy such a book. Every ex-pat experience is the same, and yet is entirely different. Adam Gopnik's writing is extremely enjoyable, but i do believe they took an apartment in Neuilly?

(seriously, that was a really catty comment and it might not be even true, i might be remembering wrong. So i strive for SOME fairness here at least. Even if this is my blog and i can write whatever the hell i want!)

Anyway my personal little Parisian-birth story didn't turn out as well as the Gopnik's. No quick-thinking French doctor (whatever he was wearing) saved Nicolas. Our family does not have a dual-citizenship child running around here. Hell, it's not Adam Gopnik's fault! It's not even the fault of my doctors -- by the time i came in to the hospital, my little boy was already gone. And two weeks before that, everything had looked perfect. Who knew that these sorts of things could happen? Obviously not me...

What's the point? There is no point. Some people have beautiful lives, other people get shit on a stick. I would put myself squarely in the middle of those two extremes, actually. So i should not complain too much.

Somehow the meandering mind got on this subject tonight (i can trace it for you: Lauralu mentions Calvin Trillin in passing, amongst many more important things; New Yorker columnists; *Smash* into THAT brick wall) and there i am. It's stupid. And of course, when i went to find the link to the book it showed the cover, a small boy (their son, presumably) playing in the Jardin de Luxembourg. So, THAT did not help.

Here is a picture, for Nicolas' scrapbook, of the Jardin de Luxembourg.

Is there any other place in Paris more kid-friendly? Not that i know of. All the parents take their kids there. The older ones play in the play structure, or rent boats to play with in the fountain
(i remember i did this with A on one of our first days in Paris, right after i had nearly lost him on the Metro by accident...) And the babies are promenaded by their proud mothers. We also had a proper European baby carriage, that my mother had bought for A. years ago. I really did look forward to taking Nicolas there, in that baby carriage, like a proper French baby...and then later in life (since we would be moving back to the states), bringing him back to do the boats.

Instead all i got was a few meltdowns when approaching the gates -- i think i was able to walk through the Jardin de Luxembourg once after he died and before we left town, and only because i refused to be a basket case about a stupid place.

Ok, i guess i am done now with that little excursion into the might-have-beens.

4 comments:

Julie said...

(((((((Catherine))))))))
I wish I had more than that. I wish I had the right words to fix it all. You and I both know I would use them in a minute. But..... Well, you know. I hate Adam Gopnik right along with you though.

Catherine said...

If it helps, I'll hate him too...even though I have no idea who the heck he is other than what you've written here. (how's that for a country bumpkin?) I'm sorry you didn't get the fairy tale like he did. I'm sorry Paris isn't perfect for you like it is for him. But most of all, I'm sorry you don't have the little one to play on the boats with. If wishes were pennies...

{{{hugs}}}

(and yes...drinking + blogging = bad. but maybe you needed to get the bad out?)

laura said...

i am sorry this wound is still so angry and raw. i'm sorry my aha! moment with alice trillin triggered this pain for you. i'm glad, though, there were some redeeming features of your recent return to paris. i wish you peace, and increasing peace with paris. you deserve better than this pain.

on a related but separate note, if you're interested in ex-pat/travelogue sort of writing from someone other than adam g, you might consider paul theroux's "dark star safari" - i'm reading it now. i am not a fan of his novels, but justin discovered him recently and adores his novels (woe is me) and picked up this memoir of his trek from egypt to south africa, and i cannot put it down. theroux lived in africa 30 years before this trip, but best as i can tell he had no children there, so you could avoid that minefield.

SWH said...

I second the Dark Star Safari recommendation... I read it a few years ago and really liked it.

And I hope this doesn't sound shitty, but seeing that you haven't become a perfect never upset or angry mom whose had a loss makes me feel less insane. So when I was walking down the river trail bawling, by myself this morning, I'm ok that that has to happen sometimes. Or resigned... maybe not ok.

So I walked and cried, and you drank and blogged... it's ok. Others 'happy stories' that resemble our own seem to always make our losses feel shittier...