Friday, April 13, 2007

anger

I have a colleague who i occasionally exchange emails with about the various trials of being a working mother in academia....her field is close to mine, she is at the same stage in her career, and she has a son who is about 6 months older than C. She also had a daughter a few weeks ago, so whenever we have time (which isn't that often) we have alot to talk about.

The thing is, she had a VBAC with her daughter and has apparently been spending alot of time on mothering.com and has become rather, uh, strange? Natural? Crunchy? Irritating? Not sure how to best describe it. But our current exchanges have focused alot on birth -- her feelings about her VBAC, which has 'empowered' her, and my preparation (or lack thereof lol) for the birth of the twins. She actually said something like 'my VBAC made me feel like a real woman'....umm...okay? And she is encouraging me to read anti c-section/anti-intervention books. You know, the kind that are full of statistics about home births and 'our bodies know what to do' and whatnot. Uh-huh.

What bothers me more than anything is the level of my anger reaction to all of this. She is a friend, but not a close one. I don't remember how much we have discussed birth experiences in the past so i don't know if she is familiar with much about mine, but she does know about Nicolas. I understand that we all see things through the lens of our own experience, and i presume her c-section was extremely traumatic for her. And i understand why this is a problem -- i mean, it is one thing to say 'mother and baby are alive and healthy, you shouldn't complain.' And at some level this is true. However, it is not the whole story. If a woman has such a traumatic birth (even with surviving baby/babies) that she is diagnosed with severe PPD or PTSD as a result, clearly something went seriously wrong -- even though the worst did not happen. And that something seriously wrong has to be addressed, especially in a nation such as ours with a shockingly high c-section rate.

Right, fine. But i still want to bang my head against walls when anyone starts blathering on about their 'birth experiences' from la-la-land where babies don't die and all interventions are evil and 'our bodies know what to do'. The depth of my ire surprises me. I was up half the night last night fuming about this -- trying to calm my mind and fall asleep, because i need my sleep and i can't waste my rest time on such stupidities. But i was not able to let it go.

I don't think of myself as an angry person, but i think it is clear i have some problems with anger. It is not an emotion that i really know how to express in a constructive manner. I try to quell it, to rationalize it away...and then i either plunge into depression, or it rears it's ugly head as i freak out over very small non-events (like Alexander's habit of bounding down the stairs like a herd of elephants, or the apparent inability of anyone in my family to understand that a laundry basket specifically labelled 'whites' is not supposed to contain colors). I can't help think that this makes me rather difficult to live with. I do find usually that exercise/housework/gardening helps alot, but now that i am 'pretty huge', ahem, these things are not so reasonably done. So that doesn't leave me in a very good spot.

Or maybe i'm just being moody and hormonal. Oh, and don't forget paranoid.

(By the way, my disclaimer is the following -- anyone wanting to read my birth stories can find them here: A, Nicolas, and C)

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Honestly, I have found that my aggravation surrounding those views is based on the lack of knowledge I always seem to find hidden right behind. And a little ignorance. In othner words, a lot of the women who believe in holistic, home and water births (among other such types) have never experienced something TRULY traumatic.

I am in no way trying to minimize the pain of a traumatic delivery no matter what the outcome, but I am saying that it's never occured to most women that something could really go horribly wrong during birth. Or, maybe they just have the common perception that "it can't happen to me, *that* only happens to other people."

I sure hope I don't offend anyone by saying this. I am just speaking from the folks I have talked to. And I would be willing to bet that anyone who has experienced loss or stillbirth would probably never opt for a "natural", intervention-free birth.

So I suppose it's like you said. It's all seen from our perceptions, and your anger might be rooted in the fact that many women like that usually never have tradgedy strike them. They can talk about their la-la birth experiences and look down their noses at those of us who've experienced the death of our children simply because they don't get it.

Does this make any sense? I am trying not to ramble...but I get so angry when I hear people say that because they were healthy, natural, strong and doing everything by the book, they were "blessed" with a healthy child, blah blah blah. It always leaves me with the feeling that I must have done something wrong for two of my babies to have died.

And those of us that have been through this hell know that is not true. Natural, Vbac, drug-free, birthing center, whatever...I would be willing to bet isn't any safer than a c-section or hospital birth. In fact, the oposite may be true.

That's my two cents. Even if you weren't looking for it!

Sara said...

Yes. I understand exactly what you're talking about. I get ENRAGED at the statement, "our bodies know what to do," precisely because it seems to be true for some people, but clearly not me. So what does that mean about me and my body? I'm not sure how I would react if someone wanted me to read an anti-intervention book. Would I nod and smile politely, or do the socially inappropriate thing and share some horror stories?

I don't know.

Elizabeth said...

I am a lurker, I think, and have been reading for a while. Sorry not to have commented earlier. I'm pregnant with #2 at www.devriesthree.blogspot.com if you want to check me out. I just wanted to put my perspective in there... I have been lucky enough, in my previous and this pregnancy so far, not to have experienced any trauma such as you have. I know that there is no way I would choose not to have all the possible help available to me as I deliver my child. I feel like these technologies have been invented to help us when our bodies aren't and things are not going as "planned." Does that make sense? Good luck with this pregnancy, I will be following along, thinking of you and your family...

Lori said...

I understand your anger. But even more so because this woman knows of your experience, your loss of Nicolas, and is still finding it appropriate to preach to you. I don't know her, but I find that more than a little insensitive.

As a woman who has had to undergo fertility therapy to conceive all of my children, I gave up a long time ago on the idea that having babies is something that comes "naturally" to all of us. Sometimes our bodies really do fail us, and our babies. And sometimes, medical intervention can step in and save the day. So, for me personally, I felt most comfortable having my babies in a high level hospital with well trained medical professionals. That's just me though.

Rosepetal said...

I don't think the examples you cited mean that you have "a problem with anger." Or okay, so do I.

like Alexander's habit of bounding down the stairs like a herd of elephants, or the apparent inability of anyone in my family to understand that a laundry basket specifically labelled 'whites' is not supposed to contain colors .

Check and check. That would piss me off too. It doesn't make you difficult to live with. It makes them difficult to live with LOL!

Down to the serious stuff.

This woman is insensitive and aggravating given that she knows about Nicolas. She would make me fume too.

The general question about birth experience does piss me off. I really honestly don't give a flying f*ck about the birth experience and I personally think people who are fixated on that have their priorities mixed up. I care about the experience of taking a healthy alive baby home from the hospital and having the rest of my life to spend on motherhood.

Even though when Moksha was born, my life wasn't in any danger and this wasn't the choice at all (there was no choice since he already had died), I have wished so many times that I could have had a chance to say let me die so that he can live.

If I am honest with myself, before it happened to me, I certainly didn't think it could happen to me. I'm pretty sure my friends still don't think it could happen to them either. I think you have to live it to truly understand that babies can and do die for known and unknown causes.

delphi said...

Before C. died, I was a wee bit of a "my body knows what to do" type. No, I would never have considered a home water birth. Ever. Period. But I did have a birth plan that said "don't give me drugs, don't intervene unless totally necessary, and don't give me an episiotomy. Then I arrived at the hospital and they said he was dead. So give me all the drugs, give me an epidural, give me the episiotomy, just get me baby out of my horrible body that failed him.

Now I just want to shake those who preach that sermon. Seriously!?! Hospitals are SOOOO much different than they were in our parent's time. They are set up more like birthing centers all the time. In our area, no matter which hospital you deliver in, you have a private room with dimmed lights and a nice spot for your husband to settle down with you. The nurses let you walk around, there is a jet tub to soak in, they've got a birthing ball, you can bring in music to listen to. And there is a complete OR just seconds away with a full compliment of staff.

Even with BB's birth, when I thought that I would need to have the FHR monitor on all the time to keep my sanity, I didn't. I would walk for 15 minutes, then they would put the monitor on for a few minutes, check him, check my bloodpressure, then up again to walk around. I was mobile until they broke my water and inserted the epidural.

So, here it is, I think anyone who goes all cruchy-granola-I'm-delivering-at-home is nuts. The hospital was accomadating, the staff was exceptionally nice, and we had an amazing birth experience. All right next door to an OR and NICU.

Off my soapbox I go...

long35acre said...

waI have those moments of anger. I'm quite good at blocking things, which I don't think has helped me in the long run. Because when those blocked things inevitably rear their ugly heads weeks, months, years down the line..... well they are ugly.

I used to think "that can't happen to me" too. I used to be against induction and c-sections. I thought it made perfect sense that our bodies "knew what to do". *Sigh* Sucks not be an innocent anymore.

Anonymous said...

I'm with Lori:

I understand your anger. But even more so because this woman knows of your experience, your loss of Nicolas, and is still finding it appropriate to preach to you. I don't know her, but I find that more than a little insensitive.

This woman is a total a-hat. I don't think you have an anger problem. Don't doubt yourself. She's an @ss.

SWH said...

This is always something that is hard for me to deal with... especially since i was a little on the 'natural birth' side of things... however, i ALWAYS acknowledged that medical intervention was a good thing when it was needed (otherwise i wouldn't be here- i was a c-section).

I don't know if you've read it, but on Ask Moxie, in her series about PPD there is a post about her definition of a "good" birth. I like the ideas she includes in this post... she recognizes that losing a baby in labor is a tragedy worse than a bad birth experience and totally separates that out of the discussion (in a respectful way). Then she talks about the basis of a good birth being that the woman feels like her voice was respected and that she is generally at peace with what happened... i took it as a recognition that the difference between good and bad births is personal... and that women can not define what a good birth is for another woman because her desires/expectations are her own.

Also, the pushy attitude that some 'crunchy/natural birth types' have makes everything they say more annoying (and enraging).

niobe said...

It's absolutely true. I am infuriated when someone talks about the trauma she experienced during birth or how she feels like a failure as a woman because she had an epidural or a c-section.

As you say, yes, these women are in fact very upset or even devastated by their experience. But it's only because they honestly can't imagine anything worse happening to them.

But there's really no excuse for this woman if she knows about Nicolas. Would it help soothe your anger if you, um, reminded her?