Tuesday, January 22, 2008

set, subset

"I no live in Detroit", said C as we were driving home from school."The other kids live in Detroit but i no live in Detroit."

"Really? Where do you live then?"

"I live in North America."

"But C, Detroit is in, i mean, it's a part of....ok, we'll see at home. We'll look on Google Earth and see."

Three days later, i finally have Google Earth downloaded, the internet working, and the babies in bed.

"C, come look at this!"

"Oooooh, it's the earf! Dere are the continents! Dere Europe, and Ay-see-ah and North America and South America and Afwica."

Well, it's good to know that she learns something in school.

So we zoom in, and do the country, state, city.

"Now, check this out, we can find our house."

"We can?"

So, i find our street, our house.

"No, that not our house"

"Yes, it is, it is just seen from the top. Look, you can see Nicolas' tree! Isn't that cool, you can see Nicolas' tree!"

I admit i am sometimes easily amused. But really i was excited to see Nicolas' tree from space. It felt like an accomplishment, somehow, like he accomplished something. How fucked-up is that? Don't answer. (Last time i checked, you couldn't see it, because they do not update this thing regularly, and i do not look regularly).

"Who is Nicolas?"

"Nicolas is your brother who died."

Now i looked at her and realized she was seconds away from a meltdown so i changed topics abruptly.

"Look there is Miss R's house! And Miss K's!! Let's go look for your school, do you want to go look for your school? Your school is over here! There is the church!"

She sort of lost interest at that point...and i am not sure if i accomplished my purpose, which was to explain that Detroit was inside North America. But she is so iffy lately (see previous post) that she melts down over everything. If she can't even deal with being left alone in a room, maybe i had better cool it with the dead sibling talk. So i have done that, but it is disturbing to me. She is in that 3-year old questioning phase, why this why that. But she is always asking about family stuff -- people, relationships, babies, marriage, etc. In contrast to A, who was always asking about trucks and cars and construction equipment. I wonder if this is boy/girl or if it is just a personality difference. I loved this phase with A, when you could just see his mind opening up and his world view forming as he put things together. I felt Nicolas' absence so keenly in that third year, as i missed this phase with him. Now C is in it, and it is so very different with her. No questions about railroads or the way things work...it's talk about 'Mommy and Daddy and me and A and M and Gheeto' and 'You got married to daddy and you had a baby and that was A and then there was me and there was M and Gheeto and i was a baby then and they are babies now' and she's playing with the toy sharks in the science museum water thing and she puts out 2 big sharks and 4 small ones to make a family and the MIL says 'oh that is so cute, do you see who it is, i must take a picture to send to my friends' and i am wondering if i am the only one any more who remembers that there is a shark missing?

8 comments:

Catherine said...

Maybe she's not ready today...but over time Nicolas will become a part of her story just like he is a part of yours.

(very cool about the tree, btw)

Julia said...

I remember. But I know that's not the point. MIL is supposed to remember, and if she doesn't, that hurts. And I understand why you want Cloe to know, and I am sure she will, in time, just like Catherine says.
Does Alexander talk about Nicolas at all? Would it help Cloe to talk to him?
And I agree-- way cool about the tree.

delphi said...

No sage words of advice, just a big hug and as much extra patience as I can afford to send you.

Rosepetal said...

No, definitely not the only one as we all know and remember Nicolas. And I think it's really cool that you can see his tree from space!

Sara said...

So cool. I'm going to see if I can figure out which tree is Nicolas's.

Your mil is difficult, to say the least.

MB said...

We go in cycles. Sometimes it's ok to talk about Audrey and sometimes she just pretends that it's not there. It's hard to be the one who can't pretend, to be the one who always remembers the missing shark. Mommies are cursed with that.

Tash said...

Bella is also v. into family arrangements right now, I think their must be a PreK rote week where this is discussed. (My favorite moment had to be when she saw two big flamingos and one little one on a lawn, "Look Mom! That baby flamingo has TWO mommies!" EXCELLENT observation, little one.) Strangely, she anthropomorphizes everything, so even her trains have relationships (she has about 4 Thomas', which are "mommy Thomas," etc.). So she both asks how things work, AND how they're related. I think it's just part of the drill. What I do have problems with is how to insert Maddy in there. Sometimes she does it herself, sometimes she doesn't and I feel uncomfortable correcting. It's a fine line between making this part of the fabric and forcing it on them. All we can do is do our best.

Julie said...

Very cool about the tree! Sending you a huge hug. I too wonder if I am the only one that remembers someone is missing. Just remember, WE notice. WE remember. (((hugs)))