Tuesday, March 18, 2008

For us stillbirth moms

There was an interesting article in the NY Times magazine a bit ago about pain in fetuses and newborn/premature babies:

The First Ache

is the link, i am not sure how long it will stay up though -- it has already been more than a month. I am the speedy blogger, to be sure. There is a bunch of nonsense in this article as well as some good stuff -- of course they have to present both sides of an issue, but one guy who is quoted is obviously a loon. The one who says that we can't experience pain until we are over a year old? Yeah, that one.

But the point of my posting this here (if you don't want to wade through the whole article) is the following paragraphs:

In the fetus, especially, we can’t deduce the presence or absence of consciousness from its anatomical development alone; we must also consider the peculiar environment in which fetuses live. David Mellor, the founding director of the Animal Welfare Science and Bioethics Center at Massey University in New Zealand, says he was prompted to consider the role of fetal surroundings in graduate school. “Have you ever wondered,” one visiting professor asked, “why a colt doesn’t get up and gallop around inside the mare?” After all, a horse only minutes old is already able to hobble around the barnyard. The answer, as Mellor reported in an influential review published in 2005, is that biochemicals produced by the placenta and fetus have a sedating and even an anesthetizing effect on the fetus (both equine and human). This fetal cocktail includes adenosine, which suppresses brain activity; pregnanolone, which relieves pain; and prostaglandin D2, which induces sleep — “pretty potent stuff,” he says.

Combined with the warmth and buoyancy of the womb, this brew lulls the fetus into a near-continuous slumber, rendering it effectively unconscious no matter what the state of its anatomy. Even the starts and kicks felt by a pregnant woman, he says, are reflex movements that go on in a fetus’s sleep. While we don’t know if the intense stimulation of surgery would wake it up, Mellor notes that when faced with other potential threats, like an acute shortage of oxygen, the fetus does not rouse itself but rather shuts down more completely in an attempt to conserve energy and promote survival.

I know many of us are troubled by the question of pain -- for those of us whose babies died inside us, we wonder: Did it hurt them? Or was it just like falling asleep? The idea that our babies were in pain and we didn't even know, much less do anything to help them...that is a thought that keeps you up at night. The doctors say 'oh, it was like falling asleep', but they don't know that. I have wrestled with this guilt for years.

But if evidence does point to the 'falling asleep' theory as being correct, well, that does not absolve my guilt but it is good to know that. Which is why i post it here, to share it with you.

2 comments:

Sara said...

Thanks Kate.

The guy who thinks babies don't feel pain until they are over a year old, I'm not sure I believe he has actually ever been near a baby. Well, I guess he has, but he clearly hasn't pain any attention to them.

Julia said...

Since I know that A suffocated, I had to think about this one. But this was also where science background helped. We struggle for air because we breathe with our lungs and have reflexes that make us fight for it. Fetuses get oxygen via hemoglobin in the blood. If there is less of it, their cells slow down and then stop. That's it-- falling asleep. It helped to know that.
I am sorry you still have the guilt. I wish it wasn't so. I do really wish that-- that I could take away the guilt. I am sorry.