Sunday, September 28, 2008

out of the blue

On Friday, we were walking home from school.

"Do daddies have babies?" asked C

"No, only women have babies. Mommies. Only mommies have babies." i said.

"Why?"

"Because only women have the right parts. We say a mommy has a baby in her belly, but it isn't really her belly. It's a special place, called a uterus, and only women have them. That's the difference between women and men."

"Oh."

We plod along in relative silence for half a block or so.

"Why did our baby die?"

**double take on my part, she has never brought up Nicolas independently before**

"You mean our baby Nicolas, why did he die?"

"Yes"

"Well, it was an accident. Sometimes accidents happen."

"But why?"

"We were at the hospital for him to be born, but he died. It was an accident."

"But why?"

"Um, we don't really know...the doctors don't know....that's the thing...um...sometimes these things happen...."

"But WHY????"

"OK, look. When the baby is inside the mommy, the baby is attached to the mommy with a cord. The baby is inside, right? So he can't eat or breathe air, but he doesn't have to, because he gets everything he needs from the cord, from his mommy. We think something went wrong with Nicolas's cord, that he couldn't get what he needed to live."

"Oh."

**silence -- she ponders this, while i wonder what the people walking around us think of this conversation**

"I don't want babies to die."

"Me neither, sweetheart."

**ok, i nearly lost it here, but i don't think she saw me tear up**

"But our babies were born, and they were alive."

"Yes, we were lucky, everything went right with M and T."

"and me too, and A too"

"Yes"

"You were more careful?"

**wow, blame the mother starts early, huh?**

"No, i was equally careful with all of you. But Nicolas died and you lived, and i don't really have an answer for why."

"Oh.......can i have a fruit snack when i get home?"

"After you eat something good for you, sure."

20 comments:

k@lakly said...

Oh, do I know how that conversation feels. Isn't it grand tho, how they just get the info they need and then they're off to rejoin their own little universe. I wish our problems were solved as easily.
xxoo

Catherine said...

If only fruit snacks distracted mommy too, huh? {{{hugs}}}

Jenny said...

Wow.....amazing how their little minds work. She is absorbing as much as she can handle and then move on to the next subject! You handled it very well and it doesn't hurt for her to see you cry for Nicolas. LOT of HUGS!!!

Rosepetal said...

the "you were more careful" made me go ooof. I am glad she asked about Nicolas independently. I often meant to ask you if A. ever talks about Nicolas as he must remember him.

On a lighter note but related to where babies come from, I personally thought this was quite funny. Angus is the funniest. Jessica is the most anatomically correct. But maybe Amy actually has it right? Who knows.

I don't know how to do the html in a box thing, so here's the link:

http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/families/article4804594.ece

Rosepetal said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
nocton4 said...

ok coffee, toast and tears for breakfast this morning here ( nothing new there then ! )
out of little mouths
big love, you wonderful mama
Denise xx

Anonymous said...

You did a great job! I always think honesty is the best policy on this one. I always answer A truthfully when he asks questions about his sisters. Now that he's a bit older, he still asks, but there are less "why's".

(((hugs)))

Kerrie said...

Oh Kate...that must have been quite a moment for you. I wish it were as simple as all that.

I love that she thinks about Nicolas, that she is comfortable in asking you questions and that once she was satisfied with the answers that she just moved to the next thought.

I caught my breath while reading, I can only imagine what it did to you.

Many (((((((hugs)))))))

msfitzita said...

Wow. Sending (((HUGS))) across the miles for having to have that conversation (which you handled so beautifully, I might add).

Julie said...

You handled that well, but I am so sorry you had to handle it at all. (((hugs)))

Sara said...

Oiy.

You impress me. You handled that so well.

Ouch.

comingaroundagain said...

Oh Kate - that made tears come to me. . . No we don't really have an answer for 'why' for sure. So sad. Life is strange (but there is sweetness to be found).

Anonymous said...

The rawness of that conversation is beautiful. I had a sister who died (over 30 years ago, I still miss her)...I think as a mother you handled this beautifully.

Karin said...

I'm starting to have those conversations as well with Master M.

Gosh, the 'you were more careful?' part. Ouch. Oof is right. (((((hugs))))

Sigh.........just right there with you. :-(

Travelwahine said...

Sounds a lot like conversations with my 6 year old son.

Dr. Joanne Cacciatore said...

Oh my gosh...this brought me to tears...

Lori said...

I had a similar conversation with Little T recently. He's 10 so his questions were a bit more specific (not just, why) but that was still the crux of the matter. It was a difficult conversation but still a gift in its own way. I'm glad he remembers and that he feels he can come to me with his remembering.

You handled this beautifully.

Anonymous said...

Sniff! Yup, candy is the only followup to these conversations. As you recall at the funeral home when you came with me, J saw Mom in the casket and then saw candy. "Grandma, dead. CANDY!!!!!"

Poor you...what a conversation.

Anonymous said...

Sniff! Yup, candy is the only followup to these conversations. As you recall at the funeral home when you came with me, J saw Mom in the casket and then saw candy. "Grandma, dead. CANDY!!!!!"

Poor you...what a conversation.

Anonymous said...

Sniff! Yup, candy is the only followup to these conversations. As you recall at the funeral home when you came with me, J saw Mom in the casket and then saw candy. "Grandma, dead. CANDY!!!!!"

Poor you...what a conversation.