prescription
I was rather struck by this comment, left on one of these many NY Times stories about depression and psychoanalysis:
"As a psychotherapist for 20 years, who once was myself a patient, I must protest the drugging of America in the name of healing. Certainly, in some conditions such as true schizophrenia and severe bipolar illness, appropriate medication can be a life-saver. But for most people, psychotropic drugs are a chemical straitjacket which keeps the patient in a debilitating situation which needs adjustment, such as a dysfunctional marriage to a tyrant (needs divorce) or employment by a sadist (needs a job change). Anxiety and depression are nature's way of making us so uncomfortable we are motivated to alter out situation. To be blunt, so far as I'm concerned, prozac and ritalin are glorified pot and cocaine; such med should be used very judiciously; getting enough sunlight, exercise, involvement with loving people, meaningful work, and healthy eating are my prescription for most of my clients, as well as for myself."
Yeah, i think he overstates the case a little there. Still, i am mired in my own unhealthy moods and i tried drugs already and that didn't work. So it seems to me that the prescription at the end is not such a bad one at that. In fact, if i *could* just be a little more active, and find myself some `meaningful work', i do think that would go a long way toward solving my problems.
So i started going to the gym, like honestly, really i am. This is embarrassing -- i have a payroll deduction to give me access to the gym at school, which i signed up for seven years ago. In that seven years, i had never once even been in the gym building.
Well, my summer schedule is a little different than the usual one, so i started to go to the gym in the morning. I went last week, and this week i signed up with a personal trainer once a week so i *have* to go now. It's good. It actually does help the mood, helps the anger. It would be great to lose weight and be in shape and not flabby, but my goal is not so much weight loss but just to be mentally healthier. The trainer says i eat badly and drink too much. Well, that is true. He said we would work on that.
So my plan is to get into a rhythm so that when the winter hits, i still go, and i hope it will help. That, and the sun lamp, and doing some real work, is my plan for next winter. And if that isn't working, then back to the therapist/psychiatrist to try another med if i have to.

6 comments:
Honestly, I don't agree with that quote at all. I get really aggravated when I hear people say that exercise, love and a good sun lamp will cure a whole myriad of chemical brain imbalances. I just don't believe that to be true.
I have a loving family, I see a therapist, I exercise at least three times a week, I eat right, and I get plenty of sleep. None of this helps my OCD and anxiety to disappear. It does help make it less severe, but I just can't go without meds. I have tried several times, and each time has landed me in a terrible state where I can't leave the house.
I hope that you can find the answer that works for you. But, don't discount a good therapist and psychiatrist. Finding the right combo might be just what you need.
For me, right now, drugs would just mask what makes me less than ideally functional. But I am functional, and can see the light at the end of the tunnel. I hope all you need is some exercise and meaningful work, and that you will feel better and accomplish all you want.
I really don't know enough to voice an opinion, but I care about your, friend, and am sad you're having such a tough time.
Yeah, Kathy, that's what i meant when i said he overstated the case. Certainly these are chemical brain imbalances and they are real -- and everybody is different. So to refuse to use or even try meds is kind of stupid, really. They're just a tool, after all. The trick is to find the right thing, that works. Which i think is mostly trial & error at this point...
I shall let you know as soon as I can tell if ditching 200 pounds of husband is as good as a daily Prozac supplement.
Yes, 'anon', in your case i suspect it might even be better than Prozac!
Post a Comment