Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Thursday, December 4, 2008

A question of language

This is a comment that became a post...a reply to Charlotte's Mama who asked what words hurt us, after sharing her own.

I don't at all mind the word 'stillbirth'. I think it is a very correct description of the event, and more than that it is gentle in it's way. 'Still', come on here -- aren't we really saying 'dead'? But it is not called 'deadbirth'. Already, the use of the word 'still' is an attempt to shield us from the horror of the event.

But yes, it is an event we are describing. I had a still birth, rather than a live birth, and my son was stillborn. 'Stillborn' refers to his state, it describes him, it is a way to avoid saying 'dead at birth'. It is an adjective. The word 'stillbirth' is a noun, but it refers to the event, not the child. It is shocking to me, always, when i hear or read 'a stillborn' -- the word stillborn used as a noun, to refer to a baby. What a awful way to refer to a beautiful baby.

The word fetus, now let me have my say about that. I have worked long and hard in my own head to let go of my negative and angry feelings toward this word. It too, is a word that is descriptive -- of a state of human development. Like, say, zygote, embryo, neonate, infant, child, or adolescent. A fetus is a baby before the event of birth, and a neonate is a baby after the event of birth. Why is this a big deal? Why is it a big deal for me?

The problem is that this word, a perfectly good word for use in medical & scientific literature, was hijacked years ago in the States by the pro-choice movement. It was not used to mean 'a baby before birth', it was used to imply (and sometimes even state) 'not a baby until birth' -- that is to say, not a person yet. Big difference. And very painful to many of us who have lost a baby before birth -- how can you say he was not a person? I know so little of him -- everything about him is a mystery. I have lost a whole life of watching someone i love grow and learn. There is such a great love, and there is so little to attach it to, so few memories, so few facts. And now someone dares imply that this is worthless, this great love -- that it is all a chimera, because there was nothing to attach it to in the first place, because there was no person there? No, sorry, i don't think so.

But that is not the fault of the word fetus, that is the fault of the politics that has surrounded it for years. Yes, Nicolas was a fetus when he died, and so what? He was still a person who was here and is gone, who is missed every day, and whose worth is unknown and unmeasurable. But that worth was there, it is not to be discounted. And can not be discounted, by a simple word...a simple word which, quite frankly, merely describes his age. I do not appreciate it when people hijack words, for their own benefit. I will not allow it. I will take them back.

Friday, November 7, 2008

read this

I don't talk about politics here, as a rule, but i loved this article about the election:

Tears to Remember by Judith Warner (NY Times website)

It is beautifully written and expresses much of how i feel....

Tuesday, January 30, 2007

A pinch of politics

Didn't stay away very long, did i? But sometimes things come up, and one wants to talk about them, and having a blog is a way to do so. So maybe i will do better with not blogging, in the later part of the week.

I usually don't talk about politics here...in general i like to keep out of politics in most of my life. But yesterday i was driving to pick up A, and listening to President Bush being interviewed on NPR. Of course, Iraq and the proposed troop 'surge' was a big subject of discussion. They had a taped question for the Prez from a soldier who is currently stationed in Iraq, and the question was (paraphrased) 'If the surge doesn't work, what are you going to do then?' Bush's response was (also my paraphrase) 'Many advisors and generals assure me that the troop surge will work. We just gotta give it a chance.' Translation -- i have no freaking idea what i am going to do. Okay then.

The thing is this. We have been in this war for nearly 4 years, and it has taken this guy this long to admit that it isn't going 'as well as we would have hoped.' Yeah, you invade a country and plunge it into civil war -- indeed that is not going as well as anybody would have hoped -- and then you pointedly refuse to believe for years that there even is a problem with your approach. Then when it is impossible to deny the problem any further, what do you choose to try? Throwing a few more soldiers at the problem and hoping that will work. Yes, the military advisors say it will work. Why, they have been begging for more troops for about 3 years now. Probably, 3 years ago a large escalation would have helped quell the problems that are currently going on there. At this stage, i am not so sure, and 21,000 troops really isn't all that many anyway -- and addition of 15% to what is already there, possibly (not sure of the numbers)? What upsets me more than anything, though, is the sheer refusal on this fellow's part to admit and confront the reality.

You would think that nearly four years would be more than enough for even the most dense of human beings to look at a problem and say 'this is not working, we have to try something else'. Four years is, in fact, quite a long time. I know this very well, myself. How do i know it? Because one day before the ground invasion of Iraq, i was sitting in front of my friend's bookstore talking politics with a bunch of book people i had just met, drinking wine and eating couscous. They were drinking wine, that is -- i was not, since i was heavily pregnant. 'If i don't see you before he comes, have a good birth!', said the one lady as i left to go home that night. Not that i knew at the time that Nicolas was probably past all help already and i could have drank all the wine in the world. The next day i went to the hospital and found out he was dead, and my husband and i sat there watching the invasion of Iraq on CNN as we waited for the induction drugs to work. It was an odd thing, really -- watching the start of a war which you know will claim many lives, and waiting for the birth of your own dead baby. It was an odd thing.

So yeah, i know exactly how long it has been, and every year in March when the newscasters start talking about 'another year of war in Iraq and XXX dead and YYY destroyed', i remember my own dates and their curious coincidence with the war. I remember my own past four years, things accomplished (many) and things changed (many) and things left undone (many many). Granted i am only trying to build a stable life, not a stable 'democratic nation', but on the other hand i don't have nearly the level of resources that Mr. Bush does. So, yes, it still boggles my mind that politically we are this pass now, because i cannot let go of the fact that four years is a long time. Yes, it is -- it is very, very long.

Tuesday, November 7, 2006

Misplaced anger, righteously expressed at the voting booth *updated*

When we moved to Michigan, it was 2003 and a few months after Nicolas had died. During the next year, i of course had my own set of 'dead-baby-related' political issues that i was suddenly interested in and aware of. Certificates of stillbirth, pregnancy & infant loss awareness day, funding (or lack thereof) for medical research associated with infant loss, record-keeping (or lack thereof) which made it difficult to even get accurate statistics, what have you. All of which issues are important to our little community but probably not very interesting to the average denizens of suburbia. What, instead, animated the ladies of suburbia in that fall and spring of 2003-2004? The issue of whether people should be allowed to shoot doves.

The first time we saw one of the ladies wearing placards and handing out flyers, dh and i looked at each other and said 'THAT is an issue??' In a city, in a state, in a country with a veritable smorgasbord of relevant social and political issues to pick up and be active in....these people care if some other morons want to shoot some stupid birds? When just a few miles away we have poverty and crime and homelessness and hopelessness in an astonishing array, you care about these freaking birds? I was always just so angry that people would waste their TIME on this nonsense, when noone would touch the issues i found important -- that i walked away whenever i saw these women canvassing about the goddamn doves. I was afraid of what i might say to them, if i got started. Because what kind of perfect life must you have, if this is the injustice you are passionate about?

Anyway, i thought i kind of got over it, but funny thing -- there was a ballot initiative about the very issue today. Sandwiched between other issues, of school funding and of affirmative action, there was proposition 3 -- 'Should people be allowed to shoot doves?' And all of a sudden, my old, latent anger got the best of me, and i filled in the 'Yes' circle as hard and dark as i could, with an intense glee. Take that, suburban bitches! It even makes me happy to recall it now, this tiny bit of revenge against the universe. My own vehemence surprises me.

The funny thing is, i do think it is rather, well, gauche to be shooting birds for target practice. I mean, really. I have no problem with shooting animals to eat them, but shooting them just for fun seems extremely gross. So ordinarily i would be against this sort of thing. Why shoot a pretty bird for fun? And if they are going to shoot something for fun, will somebody please come to my house and shoot the squirrels?

*******

So, the proposition didn't pass, it was voted down 2-1. So i need not feel bad that innocent songbirds are dying because of my little tantrum there. Heh. Rosepetal, i looked it up -- apparently the one year they were allowed to shoot them 'in a limited area', there were 28,000 doves shot. So, i guess there are alot of people who like to shoot things for fun... again, i offer my squirrels, first come first serve...