Well, i am no longer angry at my colleague, for one thing. Our email conversation has proceeded in the same vein (yes, niobe, i did bring up my experience with Nicolas explicitly) but i have gotten over my ire. I realized that i probably sounded exactly the same way after my first labor, in the years after A was born. Well, not exactly the same way -- actually i never talked about birth at all, being kind of embarassed that i had such an easy one. But i very much had the same mindset -- that whole 'natural' thing, including even the obsession with 'Mothering' magazine. Except they didn't have forums back then, and i didn't have a subscription because it was expensive, so all i could do was leaf through the magazine at the organic foods store.
I can't say that my mindset, such as it is, is that very much different now. I still do alot of those 'natural-parenting' things, even now with the cloth diapers. I just don't really consider it a big deal, whether one chooses one way or the other. C's birth was almost intervention-free, even though she was my subsequent pregnancy. I say 'almost' because my labor with her was induced, but i am lucky in that labor was successfully induced at term by breaking the waters...no pit drip was necessary. But it was a natural birth in that i didn't have any pain meds. We were in the hospital with my brilliant doctor in attendance (i have never been comfortable with the whole idea of home birth), but basically all he had to do was catch. So we were very lucky with her, and with A as well.
In the States, many hospitals are very interventionist, so you do have to speak up for yourself. Left to their own devices, the nurses will stick you with an IV, and epidural, and a pit drip before you can say jack robinson. If that's not what you want, you gotta argue a little. For me, it helps that i have fairly quick labors, and tend to be somewhat oppositional until i hit around 7-8 cm dilation or so. With A, i argued that i didn't want an episiotomy...with Nicolas, i argued about the exact dosage & timing of the induction drugs they were giving me (yes, with a dead baby inside me in a foreign language)...with C, i argued about the proper interpretation of the strip from the fetal monitor. DH is used to me by now so he doesn't even notice, but i do remember my mother positively goggling at me while i was scrapping it out with the nurse during my labor with C. I swear she looked at me like i was from another planet or something. It is a memory that always makes me laugh.
Anyway, i am totally wandering from my point, which is one of self-definition. I have been a mommy now for nearly 15 years, so i tend to forget those first years where all of a sudden your world revolves around your kid(s) and this is something new. And the whole definition of self, of your place in the world, changes....and breast-vs-bottle, or circumcision or not, etc. become weighty debates that so change the nature of everything. Because your new role in life is that of Mommy and in fact it is the most important role, and you are desperate to do it right. I think that is why the so-called 'mommy wars' are so acrimonious, and we all react so poorly to the thought that we are being judged. I mean, i certainly reacted badly to my colleague's insinuation that i needed to be informed about my birth choices because i expected to be induced at 37 weeks, right? So even though i pretend i am 'beyond all that', i still fall flat on my face here!
Oh, as to Kim's question about the twins -- no, there is no planned c-section. All my births have been vaginal deliveries so far, so i hope to go that way with the twins too. My OB supports this as long as they are positioned well, which is really the question -- they are currently both transverse breech so we will see...they have plenty of time to flip but i wonder if they have plenty of space! Looks kinda crowded in there, to be honest...