Saturday, February 24, 2007

Book review -- "Dear Cheyenne"

It is funny that britmum should mention "Dear Cheyenne" in her comment to the previous review as i was just re-reading it tonight in order to write about it...completeness, you know. I love this book. It is truly wonderful. It's the only one i actually read in the first year after Nicolas died, and is the one i usually put in the hospital baskets when i can afford it. The only reason i didn't suggest it to the center is because i do think they would be looking for something different...i don't know, exactly, but it just didn't seem to fit for that idea. But anyway, since i was writing reviews, i figured i had to include it, so here it is.

"Dear Cheyenne" by Joanne Cacciatore-Garard is a book which doesn't quite fit in as either 'practical' or 'philosophical'...it is essentially a personal story -- the narrative of Joanne's own grief journey after the death and stillbirth of her daughter Cheyenne. (and yeah i should write Ms. Cacciatore, or rather Dr. Cacciatore, but heck i 'know' Joanne online have exchanged emails with her so it just feels wierd to do that). Sure, "Life touches life" was a personal story too, but in that book i got the impression that Ms. Ash was most interested in sharing her philosophical conclusions...whereas Joanne does indeed share the 'nitty-gritty', as Catherine put it. She does so in the letters and poems she wrote to her daughter over the years, starting with a few hours after Cheyenne's birth. The raw pain is there....and so is the evolution of it, over the years.

When i read this book for the first time, it was probably about 5 months after Nicolas died. I had found the MISS website and forums (the group Joanne founded) and had gotten much support there in those first months...Joanne's book was suggested there by many people and so i bought it. It did help me a little to read it -- especially seeing the evolution of her pain, all the things she accomplished afterward, the events she has set in motion and the people she has helped. I am seriously impressed with Joanne.

Reading it again tonight, after reading a bunch of others, was interesting -- i could compare, you know. This is the only book i actually cried while reading...i mean, more than a few tears now & then. Which is a big thing for me, i have trouble crying usually, at least anymore. So i would say now it helped me to read it too. I would say it's the best of the ones i have read, but then again i prefer reading a personal story.

Let's see, practical things -- it is a quick read, a thin book. Most of the book is Joanne's letters and poems, but there are 20 pages or so at the end with resources, suggestions (if your child has just died), symptoms of normal grief, quotes from other bereaved parents, etc. I'm not sure if it is available on amazon...i have always just ordered it directly from MISS.

2 comments:

Rosepetal said...

I haven't read this one. Maybe I will get myself a copy. I think, aside from the practical suggestions of a book like Empty Cradle, it's true that some of the most useful books are the ones where stories are shared. I think this is why reading other people's blogs is so helpful as well. It helps to relieve the "why was I *chosen* for this when she and she and she wasn't" a little bit and relieves the isolation a little too.

I cannot believe how many books you have read so quickly (and I'm generally a fast reader). And may I say internet mommy is well and truly back! I'm happy!

PinkCat said...

I met the author of this book the January after Annabel died which was only 2 months. It was such a profound moment to meet someone who had written such a heart rendering book. She was so very normal and I just sat there and cried. It was wonderful to see that eventually I would feel human again. She gave me my copy of the book there. I had read her website and my husband had a business trip coming up for us to go to Phoenix so I emailed her and asked if I could meet her. She lives in Arizona and now so do I.

So when we came to make our support packs that was the first book I wanted in there.

Great review of the book.

Take care and hugs to you.