Showing posts with label book reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book reviews. Show all posts

Saturday, February 24, 2007

Book review -- "Dear Cheyenne"

It is funny that britmum should mention "Dear Cheyenne" in her comment to the previous review as i was just re-reading it tonight in order to write about it...completeness, you know. I love this book. It is truly wonderful. It's the only one i actually read in the first year after Nicolas died, and is the one i usually put in the hospital baskets when i can afford it. The only reason i didn't suggest it to the center is because i do think they would be looking for something different...i don't know, exactly, but it just didn't seem to fit for that idea. But anyway, since i was writing reviews, i figured i had to include it, so here it is.

"Dear Cheyenne" by Joanne Cacciatore-Garard is a book which doesn't quite fit in as either 'practical' or 'philosophical'...it is essentially a personal story -- the narrative of Joanne's own grief journey after the death and stillbirth of her daughter Cheyenne. (and yeah i should write Ms. Cacciatore, or rather Dr. Cacciatore, but heck i 'know' Joanne online have exchanged emails with her so it just feels wierd to do that). Sure, "Life touches life" was a personal story too, but in that book i got the impression that Ms. Ash was most interested in sharing her philosophical conclusions...whereas Joanne does indeed share the 'nitty-gritty', as Catherine put it. She does so in the letters and poems she wrote to her daughter over the years, starting with a few hours after Cheyenne's birth. The raw pain is there....and so is the evolution of it, over the years.

When i read this book for the first time, it was probably about 5 months after Nicolas died. I had found the MISS website and forums (the group Joanne founded) and had gotten much support there in those first months...Joanne's book was suggested there by many people and so i bought it. It did help me a little to read it -- especially seeing the evolution of her pain, all the things she accomplished afterward, the events she has set in motion and the people she has helped. I am seriously impressed with Joanne.

Reading it again tonight, after reading a bunch of others, was interesting -- i could compare, you know. This is the only book i actually cried while reading...i mean, more than a few tears now & then. Which is a big thing for me, i have trouble crying usually, at least anymore. So i would say now it helped me to read it too. I would say it's the best of the ones i have read, but then again i prefer reading a personal story.

Let's see, practical things -- it is a quick read, a thin book. Most of the book is Joanne's letters and poems, but there are 20 pages or so at the end with resources, suggestions (if your child has just died), symptoms of normal grief, quotes from other bereaved parents, etc. I'm not sure if it is available on amazon...i have always just ordered it directly from MISS.

Book review -- "Empty Cradle, Broken Heart"

Our next selection is "Empty Cradle, Broken Heart: Surviving the Death of your Baby" by Deborah Davis. And after typing out all these titles i am wondering why all these books have such long ones.

I am afraid this is the fourth book i read in as many days, so i kind of have dead-baby-book fatigue. I did not read this one very carefully -- i read a few parts carefully, and skimmed the rest. So it probably deserves a better reading and if i ever make one i will append it here.

Nevertheless, i can certainly say this is a very useful book. It is much like an extended, more in-depth version of 'Empty Arms', review here. There is significantly more in it, though, and would be more relevant for a longer period of time. It goes into causes, physical recovery, emotional recovery, doing memory stuff (she calls it 'affirming your baby'), and many special situations (loss of one of multiples, disconnecting life support, terminating a wanted pregnancy, etc.) There is a chapter just for fathers, one about family relationships, and several chapters on subsequent pregnancy and parenting the subsequent child. The philosophical questions behind loss are dealt with only briefly, and much as in 'Empty Arms'. As usual there are many quotes from bereaved parents who have known all kinds of losses.

I flipped to the end of the 'subsequent pregnancy' chapter to read the bit entitled 'Another loss' and just had to laugh. It sounded awfully familiar! It turned out this is the book Catherine quoted after Travis died, as an example of how her situation was 'off the charts' in a certain sense. Even in this book which tries so hard to cover all the bases and explain everything, all they can say about another loss is 'you will probably find the courage to try again' and 'you are probably more resilient than you think'. Sigh.

But that is not a judgement against this book -- overall i think it is an excellent book that falls squarely in the 'practical' category (i suppose we could label all of these books as either 'practical' or 'philosophical' treatments of child loss issues). Maybe 'Empty Arms' would be better to have in the hospital, because a longer, more in-depth book can be overwhelming. But as an overall resource for the first year, this one seems pretty darned good.

Friday, February 23, 2007

Book review -- "Safe in the arms of God"

Okay, "Safe in the arms of God: Truth from Heaven About the Death of a Child" by John MacArthur. What do i say about this one? Oy. I admit, i was warned -- S. said 'it's heavily Christian, and i hate his writing'. Not the best of recommendations to be sure. Yet i thought it might be a book which would fly well at the center, you know, because most of those women are pretty heavily Christian themselves. But okay, not even. Not of this bent.

The best thing i can say about this book is that the cover is pretty, and the title is written in an attractive font. The next best thing i can say is that it is hardcover (which unfortunately means it cost *me* a pretty penny), but this is useful. Presumably the author was thinking that the usefulness of the hard cover was that the eager reader could thumb through it often, soaking up his wisdom. I personally think that the usefulness of the hard cover is that if someone were to give it to you, and you were not of the same philosophical bent as the author, the book would make a most satisfying thunk sound as it intersected with the giver's head. You just can't get that effect with a paperback.

Anyway, Mr. (Reverend? Pastor? Whatever) MacArthur is very big into the whole God's plan thing. The essence of this book is the following -- God is perfect and good, he has a plan for everybody, if your child died, it's because it was God's plan, and here are the passages of the Bible that say so. Your child is for sure in Heaven with Jesus now, so you should find comfort there, and you will surely see your baby after you die (as long as you are a good Christian of course). It is a very theological book....it attempts to comfort with scripture and argument, as well as with the testimonies of other like-minded bereaved parents. These testimonies i found to be very heart-rending, and certainly more interesting and beautiful than MacArthur's theological arguments or his heavy-Christian talk of heathens and pagans going to hell and whatnot.

Okay, you see, i am trying to be fair with this book. I should have known what i was getting into, i do know that these beliefs comfort many people, and i do not wish to put down that worldview. It doesn't exactly cut it for me, clearly, but hey, whatever works, right? I think that if you agree with the religion and philosophy here, this would probably be a helpful book for you. Unfortunately, i think that near-complete agreement is necessarily a prerequisite for reading this book without some level of ire.

My verdict overall -- i would never give this book to a stranger. I like my head the way it is, i don't need anyone throwing things at it. I do think it may be of interest to someone who agrees with it to begin with. If you are such a person and want to read it, send me an email at kate_baloh@yahoo.com...i have an extra, nearly-unread copy that i don't know what to do with.

Book review -- "Empty Arms"

The next book i read was "Empty Arms: Coping After Miscarriage, Stillbirth and Infant Death" by Sherokee Isle. Mind you there are two different dead-baby books with the title "Empty Arms", so far i have only read one.

This is a little thin book with alot of information. I did not read it extremely carefully as it comes pretty tightly bound and i was afraid i would make it look too 'used' to donate. But i skimmed, well enough.

I thought this book was an excellent resource to have right after a loss. I think it is probably the perfect book to be in my stillbirth baskets (if i could only afford to put a book in each one on a regular basis!) It goes over all the choices that a parent who has just lost a baby has to make in the hospital and in the days beyond, and lays out options in a very reasonable and non-overwhelming way. Quotes and stories from other bereaved parents are interspersed throughout so that the newly bereaved feel less alone. She does go into the 'big questions' but does not state a specific philosophy -- it is more like 'some people feel that xxx and others feel that yyy'. The author does of course talk about her personal experiences with loss (one stillbirth and two miscarriages) but her experience is not the focus of the book. Instead, she seeks to put out a (slim) roadmap for the newly bereaved, and help them in those first steps along the path. There is a nice list of resources in the back, too, for more in-depth discussion of all these issues.

So, my verdict overall -- A useful and well-constructed book for the specific purpose of giving to someone soon after a loss. After a few months, i doubt this book would be of much use. So, doesn't work for my original purpose, but i hope it will help someone at the hospital.

Book review -- "Life touches life"

Ok, so without the internet for a week, how am i supposed to get my dead baby fix? By reading books, of course.

Seriously, i have had some unfinished business with a pile of grief books for quite some time. The story is here but the upshot is that i ordered 4-5 books dealing with stillbirth/neonatal loss with a view toward suggesting an appropriate one for the pregnancy center. At which point they sat on a pile for months because i was unable to deal with actually opening and reading them. However, the plan was always to donate the extra ones to the hospital to give to bereaved parents, and now with Nicolas' birthday coming up next month and my preparation of a donation of baskets, i really need to go through those books. So yeah, i had started reading them even before the 'net went down.

Having done so, i will write up my reviews for posterity ha ha, and if i get more books, i will do so as well.

The first book on the pile was "Life Touches Life: A Mother's story of Stillbirth and Healing" by Lorraine Ash. I had heard about this book on my yahoo support group, where one mother had read it and had some pertinent comments. Her review in a nutshell was 'not bad, but some of it was not really believable'. A specific example of that was where Lorraine Ash was talking about how she asked to be in the maternity ward after her daughter Victoria was stillborn, and would walk around and look at the other babies -- because she felt that she needed to be surrounded by life, or something. I would say that in general the author's reactions were not always typical, but obviously she is not the typical person and she took great pains to point out that everybody's journey was different. I have no problem with that, and reading her feelings that were different than mine didn't bother me. Her timeline seemed short though -- she 'healed' fast, or at least faster than i did. I think if i had read this book early, i would have thought 'i couldn't have done that at 3 months after, like she did', and stuff like that.

It is overall a book with a very positive outlook. For example, she does go through examples of stupid things people said and did, but she does not dwell on them at all -- going quickly through them and explaining why she forgave those stupid things. On the other hand, she has not had a subsequent child and therefore the book doesn't fall into even the implication that 'another baby made it all better'. The book is easy to read -- it is written in a very conversational style, directly from the heart, gently and kindly. I read it in one sitting.

The philosophical grounding of the book is rather new age-y but not necessarily in a bad way. Ms. Ash delves into the big questions and shares what she has found. She apparently comes from a Catholic background but found scant comfort there -- the old idea of 'God's plan', yadda yadda was not one she could agree with. Instead, she takes off of Rabbi Kushner's book 'When Bad Things Happen to Good People', which i haven't read so i can't really speak of. But Ms. Ash's idea is that though God may have created nature, he may not be the controller of all of nature. There is a randomness in nature that is not controlled, and the infection (Strep B) that killed Victoria, and nearly her mother, was just too strong for God to stop. So that's her 'answer', in a nutshell (okay, does that count as a spoiler?), and her way of coping is to see and feel the essence of her daughter all around her, in all things. Hence the title -- life touches life, always, even after a life is 'over' in a corporeal sense.

So, my verdict overall -- a good book, philosophical without being overbearing, definitely worth a read, even years after the death of a baby.