Saturday, February 24, 2007

Book review -- "Empty Cradle, Broken Heart"

Our next selection is "Empty Cradle, Broken Heart: Surviving the Death of your Baby" by Deborah Davis. And after typing out all these titles i am wondering why all these books have such long ones.

I am afraid this is the fourth book i read in as many days, so i kind of have dead-baby-book fatigue. I did not read this one very carefully -- i read a few parts carefully, and skimmed the rest. So it probably deserves a better reading and if i ever make one i will append it here.

Nevertheless, i can certainly say this is a very useful book. It is much like an extended, more in-depth version of 'Empty Arms', review here. There is significantly more in it, though, and would be more relevant for a longer period of time. It goes into causes, physical recovery, emotional recovery, doing memory stuff (she calls it 'affirming your baby'), and many special situations (loss of one of multiples, disconnecting life support, terminating a wanted pregnancy, etc.) There is a chapter just for fathers, one about family relationships, and several chapters on subsequent pregnancy and parenting the subsequent child. The philosophical questions behind loss are dealt with only briefly, and much as in 'Empty Arms'. As usual there are many quotes from bereaved parents who have known all kinds of losses.

I flipped to the end of the 'subsequent pregnancy' chapter to read the bit entitled 'Another loss' and just had to laugh. It sounded awfully familiar! It turned out this is the book Catherine quoted after Travis died, as an example of how her situation was 'off the charts' in a certain sense. Even in this book which tries so hard to cover all the bases and explain everything, all they can say about another loss is 'you will probably find the courage to try again' and 'you are probably more resilient than you think'. Sigh.

But that is not a judgement against this book -- overall i think it is an excellent book that falls squarely in the 'practical' category (i suppose we could label all of these books as either 'practical' or 'philosophical' treatments of child loss issues). Maybe 'Empty Arms' would be better to have in the hospital, because a longer, more in-depth book can be overwhelming. But as an overall resource for the first year, this one seems pretty darned good.

5 comments:

Catherine said...

This was THE book I liked after losing Alex. The only one. I can't really put my finger on why. After Travis...not so much. I guess book reviews gain perspective as our circumstances change. I would still recommend it to someone suffering their first loss.

PinkCat said...

Have you ever read Dear Cheyenne?

We set up a charity for our daugher called The Annabel Harwood Trust. The Dear Cheyenne book and When a Baby Dies is the books that we provide for bereaved parents.

You can check our website out at www.ahtrust.org.

Take care

Rosepetal said...

I agree with you again on this book. I think it is a good book that you can go back to several times (and I have).

Anonymous said...

Yeah, this was the only one I really liked. Or at least the only one I found helpful.

kate said...

catherine -- yes, this is very true. Needs and perspectives change. For example, i don't think i would have been so open-minded in my review of 'Life touches life' if i had read it early in my grief....

britmum -- review of Dear Cheyenne is up now! LOL