Friday, February 23, 2007

Book review -- "Life touches life"

Ok, so without the internet for a week, how am i supposed to get my dead baby fix? By reading books, of course.

Seriously, i have had some unfinished business with a pile of grief books for quite some time. The story is here but the upshot is that i ordered 4-5 books dealing with stillbirth/neonatal loss with a view toward suggesting an appropriate one for the pregnancy center. At which point they sat on a pile for months because i was unable to deal with actually opening and reading them. However, the plan was always to donate the extra ones to the hospital to give to bereaved parents, and now with Nicolas' birthday coming up next month and my preparation of a donation of baskets, i really need to go through those books. So yeah, i had started reading them even before the 'net went down.

Having done so, i will write up my reviews for posterity ha ha, and if i get more books, i will do so as well.

The first book on the pile was "Life Touches Life: A Mother's story of Stillbirth and Healing" by Lorraine Ash. I had heard about this book on my yahoo support group, where one mother had read it and had some pertinent comments. Her review in a nutshell was 'not bad, but some of it was not really believable'. A specific example of that was where Lorraine Ash was talking about how she asked to be in the maternity ward after her daughter Victoria was stillborn, and would walk around and look at the other babies -- because she felt that she needed to be surrounded by life, or something. I would say that in general the author's reactions were not always typical, but obviously she is not the typical person and she took great pains to point out that everybody's journey was different. I have no problem with that, and reading her feelings that were different than mine didn't bother me. Her timeline seemed short though -- she 'healed' fast, or at least faster than i did. I think if i had read this book early, i would have thought 'i couldn't have done that at 3 months after, like she did', and stuff like that.

It is overall a book with a very positive outlook. For example, she does go through examples of stupid things people said and did, but she does not dwell on them at all -- going quickly through them and explaining why she forgave those stupid things. On the other hand, she has not had a subsequent child and therefore the book doesn't fall into even the implication that 'another baby made it all better'. The book is easy to read -- it is written in a very conversational style, directly from the heart, gently and kindly. I read it in one sitting.

The philosophical grounding of the book is rather new age-y but not necessarily in a bad way. Ms. Ash delves into the big questions and shares what she has found. She apparently comes from a Catholic background but found scant comfort there -- the old idea of 'God's plan', yadda yadda was not one she could agree with. Instead, she takes off of Rabbi Kushner's book 'When Bad Things Happen to Good People', which i haven't read so i can't really speak of. But Ms. Ash's idea is that though God may have created nature, he may not be the controller of all of nature. There is a randomness in nature that is not controlled, and the infection (Strep B) that killed Victoria, and nearly her mother, was just too strong for God to stop. So that's her 'answer', in a nutshell (okay, does that count as a spoiler?), and her way of coping is to see and feel the essence of her daughter all around her, in all things. Hence the title -- life touches life, always, even after a life is 'over' in a corporeal sense.

So, my verdict overall -- a good book, philosophical without being overbearing, definitely worth a read, even years after the death of a baby.

5 comments:

Catherine said...

I attended her workshop at the Compassionate Friends conference last year (when we were in your neck of the woods), and she is just as 'unusual' in person as she is in her book. One of the weird things I had a hard time dealing with was that she often referred to her daughter as, "the stillbirth." It just seemed...odd. So I sort of knew what to expect when I read her book already. I don't know...I guess I want more of the nitty-gritty when I read someone's first-hand account. It was too...sanitized...yes...I think that's a pretty good word for it.

kate said...

Catherine -- yeah, that's kind of what i meant when i said it 'had a very positive outlook'. Like, even the bad stuff, she put a happy spin on. I think sanitized is an excellent description.

long35acre said...

I read her book a couple of years after Ian died. I remember being "inspired" by it because she was so positive. It was helpful to me at the time because I was going through a lot of negative stuff and to think about doing something positive was helpful.

But you are right, she is a little - I don't know - granola crunchy LOL - or something.

My mom went to a workshop of hers at the DC conference, but I couldn't go as I was attending something different. I was disappointed because I was interested in writing and thought it would be good.

Anyway - the book isn't for everyone, but I think it's "safe".

laura said...

i hated this book. so, so much. words cannot express. the whole thing about not having another child so she could commune spiritually with her stillborn daughter was just too much. i don't think she was dealing with it at all; she chose this wacky point of view to avoid dealing with the hurt. which is fine - we all do what we can - but i shouldn't have to read a book about it. big ick.

kate said...

Lauralu -- i didn't get that she didn't have another child for that reason. Did i miss something? My understanding was that since she was 40+ she was not able to concieve another naturally, and they chose not to do ART. Coming from a Catholic background as she did, a distate for fertility treatments is not suprising. But maybe i will just have to go back and read that part again...