Friday, February 23, 2007

Book review -- "Safe in the arms of God"

Okay, "Safe in the arms of God: Truth from Heaven About the Death of a Child" by John MacArthur. What do i say about this one? Oy. I admit, i was warned -- S. said 'it's heavily Christian, and i hate his writing'. Not the best of recommendations to be sure. Yet i thought it might be a book which would fly well at the center, you know, because most of those women are pretty heavily Christian themselves. But okay, not even. Not of this bent.

The best thing i can say about this book is that the cover is pretty, and the title is written in an attractive font. The next best thing i can say is that it is hardcover (which unfortunately means it cost *me* a pretty penny), but this is useful. Presumably the author was thinking that the usefulness of the hard cover was that the eager reader could thumb through it often, soaking up his wisdom. I personally think that the usefulness of the hard cover is that if someone were to give it to you, and you were not of the same philosophical bent as the author, the book would make a most satisfying thunk sound as it intersected with the giver's head. You just can't get that effect with a paperback.

Anyway, Mr. (Reverend? Pastor? Whatever) MacArthur is very big into the whole God's plan thing. The essence of this book is the following -- God is perfect and good, he has a plan for everybody, if your child died, it's because it was God's plan, and here are the passages of the Bible that say so. Your child is for sure in Heaven with Jesus now, so you should find comfort there, and you will surely see your baby after you die (as long as you are a good Christian of course). It is a very theological book....it attempts to comfort with scripture and argument, as well as with the testimonies of other like-minded bereaved parents. These testimonies i found to be very heart-rending, and certainly more interesting and beautiful than MacArthur's theological arguments or his heavy-Christian talk of heathens and pagans going to hell and whatnot.

Okay, you see, i am trying to be fair with this book. I should have known what i was getting into, i do know that these beliefs comfort many people, and i do not wish to put down that worldview. It doesn't exactly cut it for me, clearly, but hey, whatever works, right? I think that if you agree with the religion and philosophy here, this would probably be a helpful book for you. Unfortunately, i think that near-complete agreement is necessarily a prerequisite for reading this book without some level of ire.

My verdict overall -- i would never give this book to a stranger. I like my head the way it is, i don't need anyone throwing things at it. I do think it may be of interest to someone who agrees with it to begin with. If you are such a person and want to read it, send me an email at kate_baloh@yahoo.com...i have an extra, nearly-unread copy that i don't know what to do with.

6 comments:

long35acre said...

Oh, the reason! God's plan! Bwaaahaaahaaaaaa!

Ok. I guess I won't pick up that book and read it.

My SIL gave me two books after Ian died. I can't remember the titles because I basically laughed and donated them to the church. They were kind of a devotional type book where you read the story of the author and each chapter was dedicated to some bible passage or something.

I think "Life Touches Life" was one of the better ones I've read. I might have to comment on that review separately. I also read "Tender Fingerprints" by Brad Stetson which is from a dad's POV. It has been a couple of years since I read that...but I think I remember liking it well enough? I might have to dig it out and read it again.

Rosepetal said...

OK, so I've noted never to buy this book ever. Thanks.

Rosepetal said...

By the way maybe you should put this review up on Amazon or something, spread the word

Catherine said...

LOL...humorous book review of a book on such a heavy subject...only you could accomplish that! Thanks for the laugh.

delphi said...

I agree - review on Amazon.

Not my cup of tea.

laura said...

argh - it sounds even worse than "life touches life" which several people around here recommended to me and which i hated with the burning intensity of a thousand suns. thank you for putting yourself through reading this so the rest of us never have to.